Biology Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for biology researchers, academics, and students. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

A controversial concept in Biology "Group Selection", has caused confusion and conflict amongst scientists since the since the mid 1990s. The more general realm of study is termed the "unit of selection" discussion.


A simple working definition for "group selection" (edit/discuss this!) is:

"Selection for traits that would be beneficial to a population of units at the expense of an individual unit possessing the trait" (here)


"What examples of group-selection are there?"

To add more structure, perhaps answers would consider the following details:

  • Organism/Species in question
  • Unit that experiences cost in fitness
  • Group that experiences benefit in fitness
  • Group-selected trait
  • Explanation

Forward Example (trait whose presence benefits the group)

  • Organism: Homo sapiens, Humans
  • Unit: Cells and their genes
  • Group: Collection of all cells in one individual Human body
  • Group-selected trait: anti-cancer traits, e.g. apoptosis (programmed cell death) via p53 ("guardian angel" gene that "kills" cancerous cells)
  • Explanation: Apoptosis is costly to the perspective of a cell, since it kills the cell and its genes. This enables the individual as a whole to live for long enough to mate and yeild offspring. Fitness of cells relative to other cells in the body is reduced, but fitness of the genome as a whole of that individual is increased relative to other individuals of that population -as a result of cancer-directed apoptosis.

Reverse Example (trait whose absence benefits the group)

  • Organism: Cervus elaphus, Red Deer
  • Unit: Individual red deer and their genomes
  • Group: Isolated population of red deer and the population gene pool
  • Group-selected trait: Lethal potential of antlers (e.g. sharp single antler instead of two blunt antlers).
  • Explanation: Consider a one-antlered stag, whose single antler is imbued with a jagged edge and is the product of a point mutation in his genome. During a rut he is able to win against other males as his antler inflicts potentially fatal injuries. This allows him to mate many females and have many offspring - however this leaves the population at risk of becoming extinct since the mating season would either have too few males to form a rut, or due to deleterious inbreeding defects in the next generation.


Of course do not feel restrained in your answers by the above suggestions - the point is to discuss the topic and learn!

Thank you for reading.

share|improve this question
possible duplicate:… – Remi.b Nov 28 '13 at 8:38
no.. species selection is entirely different. See: – hello_there_andy Nov 28 '13 at 11:38
I might had better not to write "possible duplicate". Sorry about that. I am not quite sure of how these processes differ. So I asked this question before trying to answer yours. – Remi.b Nov 28 '13 at 11:46
For your question, would you accept examples where the group is the organism and the lower unit is the gene? You might be interested by the book genes in conflict by R. Triver and Burt. You might be interested by this post as well. – Remi.b Nov 28 '13 at 11:49
@Remi.b I do accept that as an example. In fact the other author of that book, Prof. Burt is my research supervisor!! – hello_there_andy Nov 28 '13 at 11:54

This article claims to be a new level of evidence for group selection. Its a little early to tell at this point whether the critics will be moved. They have not been in the past!

sorry if this is a bit short - its late, but i'll try to come back and do more later..

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.