Take the 2-minute tour ×
Biology Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for biology researchers, academics, and students. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Is there a publication comparing DNA yield and / or PCR-amplifiability after extraction from fruit flesh (like apples, oranges, cherries etc) in comparison to seeds of the same fruits ? I would prefer a reference, but your unpublished experience is also interesting for me.

share|improve this question
    
A quick guess is that it will be easier to extract DNA (without inhibitors) from fresh material, since the seeds are made to survive. This can cause problems in the preparation. –  Chris Jan 27 at 16:47
1  
Cell walls are a major problem for (sequencing length) DNA extraction. You will normally have more usable yield from the fruit flesh than from hard seeds. Another problem might be essential oil in the fruit flesh, though. –  skymninge Jan 28 at 7:57

1 Answer 1

It depends on the seed and fruit you're talking about.

The amount of DNA in your crushed up sample of plant matter depends on only one thing--how many cells are in your sample. Look at this diagram of a kernel of corn (U of Indiana):

corn

There are different cell densities in each area--in the endosperm, the cells can be huge (and therefore have a lower density of DNA when compared with the embryo).

Let's look at a stained mustard seed (U of London):

mustard seed histology

As you can see, the cells here are very dense. More dense means more DNA per unit sample.

As far as fruit is concerned, the same rule of thumb applies. Verner, 1938 shows some cool apple tissue histology that might give you an idea of cell density in fruit tissue (again, it will be different in different fruits--search for "fruitname histology" if you're interested).

However, now that we've talked about density, we need to actually think about getting the DNA out. The extraction process is actually much more important in terms of your final yield.

Many plant seeds contain polyphenolics, which can cause DNA degradation. This protocol (Cornell U) details many of the possible shortcomings:

These compounds have also been reported to cause difficulty in DNA purification in other plant species; polysaccharides (Murray and Thompson, 1980; Fang et al., 1992); polyphenolic compounds (Katterman and Shattuck, 1983; Couch and Fritz, 1990; Howland et al. 1991; Collins and Symons, 1992); and sticky and resinous materials (Webb and Knapp, 1990).

These contaminants can degrade DNA, but also render it unusable in PCR amplification and endonuclease digestion (Kim et al. 1997, Cornell U, EPICENTRE Biotechnologies).

Overall, there are definitely species-specific differences in fruit/seed plant DNA content. Practically, however, the most important factor in DNA yield and viability for future experimentation is sample purity and contamination. Specific fruits and seeds may contain one or more of the above contaminants, so the answer to "Seeds or fruits?" definitely depends on the species of plant you're working with.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.