Take the 2-minute tour ×
Biology Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for biology researchers, academics, and students. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In a hypothetical scenario, if you cut open a person's skull to show the live brain, and then you slowly start to crush it..

At what point would the person loose consciousness?

What would the person be feeling all this time?

Would it cause pain?

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 2 down vote accepted

It depends on what part of the brain you are "crushing."

When we do brain surgery we often do exactly what you describe. That is, we open the skull and often remove part of the brain. However, in our case usually the part we are removing is diseased or malfunctioning to begin with.

There are areas of the brain that are known as eloquent and those that are considered "not eloquent." This is an overly simplistic but educationally instructive way to classify things. Eloquent brain regions are those regions that when disturbed will cause an obvious and devastating neurological injury. Examples are primary motor/sensory cortex, broca's area, wernicke's area etc. Noneloquent areas are those that can be damaged or resected and the sequelae are less obvious. For example, you can remove quite a bit of frontal lobe before you notice a problem. However, an appropriate and sensitive behavioral test/instrument may still pick up the deficit.

Damage to the brainstem and thalamus is more devastating and even small injury to this area can cause major deficits and changes in the level of consciousness. Injury to different levels of the brainstem produces different level of consciousness. Again, it really depends on the precise location and extent of injury and there is no single answer to your question.

As the brain itself has no pain receptors the patient would not really feel much pain even if you caused major deficits. However, again it depends on the location. You could theoretically irritate thalamic sensory regions and cause chronic pain syndromes but your lesion would have to be pretty precise.

share|improve this answer
add comment

It seems there's way too many variables here. Crushing can occur in a number of ways, leading to different primary damage in different regions first and different people have a different level of system failure thresholds.

Technically, there are no pain sensors on the brain, so you wouldn't feel any pain in the classical sense. However, it's hard to determine how you would affect the pain interpretation circuits (again, "crushing" can occur a number of different ways); you could inadvertently cause pain signals.

Losing consciousness would also depend on when what region of brian is crushed. And how it's crushed. Most of our higher processing regions associated with consciousness are on the very outer surface of our brain. In one scenario, if it just gets compressed, and damage tend to accumulate in the center of the brain first, it would be a different outcome than if it was some kind of shear crushing force that damaged outer brian first.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.