Skip to main content
Notice removed Improve details by Yordan Yordanov
Bounty Ended with tsttst's answer chosen by Yordan Yordanov
Tweeted twitter.com/StackBiology/status/913271799642771457
Notice added Improve details by Yordan Yordanov
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Yordan Yordanov
edited title
Link
canadianer
  • 17.9k
  • 4
  • 51
  • 84

Can a novel protein domain arizearise de novo in Naturenature or did all protein domains evolve from a single ancestor?

deleted 750 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
canadianer
  • 17.9k
  • 4
  • 51
  • 84

Can a novel protein domain arize de novo in Nature or did all protein domains evolvedevolve from a single ancestor?

My question transverses several fields of biology, this is why I think it can't be addressed by biochemistry, genetics, evolutionary biology or origins of life research only?

I know there is extensive research into the taxonomy and evolution of protein domains and many connections are found out, and are continuing to be, found between numerous domains. However, as far as I can see, new domains always arise from preexisting ones and. I have seen no paper, in any field, showing the developingdevelopment of newa new protein domain from a random piece of DNA which just mutates a start codon and synthesizes a new protein with no apparent function. I know this is theoretically possible but has anyone seen any evidence it has happened in any form of life in any geological period of time? OR are there some other mechanisms that could generate novel domains from non-coding DNA that I have overlooked when searching the journals?

My thinking is that if it hasn't, thanif de novo protein domain generation doesn't occurr, does it meansmean that all protein domains are a kind of "progeny" of a single domain that arose at the onset of life as we know it (or may bemaybe even was the first lifeform on Earth) or am I missing something out here? I tried hard to find any paper in any field-be it protein biochemistry, molecular genetics, evolutionary biology or origins of life but I wasn't able to do it.

  It seems very strange to me that this hasn't been pointed out by now thinkingsince it's a relatively very simple deduction and I thought someone somewhere should had done some research on that or even just plain stated the hypothesis. SoThus, I'm asking either for a reference paper showing evidence for the evolution of de novode novo protein domain unknown by nowdomains from a random piece of DNA that somehow managed to turn into a gene or for a reference to a paper discussing the idea that all proteins originate from a common ancestor existing at the onset of life and even, possibly, a single domain as old as life itself?

P.S. Am I mislooking something or is this hypothesis something new for molecular biology-with all that effort gone into identifying relationships between protein domains I'm thinking it's very strange no one has hypothesized a single "mother" domain for all life. Are there some mechanisms that could generate novel domains from non-coding DNA I had overlooked when searching the journals and if there are to what field do then pertain to?

Can a novel protein domain arize de novo in Nature or did all protein domains evolved from a single ancestor?

My question transverses several fields of biology, this is why I think it can't be addressed by biochemistry, genetics, evolutionary biology or origins of life research only?

I know there is extensive research into the taxonomy and evolution of protein domains and many connections are found out and are continuing to be found between numerous domains. However, as far as I can see new domains always arise from preexisting ones and I have seen no paper showing the developing of new protein domain from a random piece of DNA which just mutates a start codon and synthesizes a new protein with no apparent function. I know this is theoretically possible but has anyone seen any evidence it has happened in any form of life in any geological period of time?

My thinking is that if it hasn't, than, does it means all protein domains are a kind of "progeny" of a single domain that arose at onset of life as we know it (or may be even was the first lifeform on Earth) or am I missing something out here? I tried hard to find any paper in any field-be it protein biochemistry, molecular genetics, evolutionary biology or origins of life but I wasn't able to do it.

  It seems very strange to me this hasn't been pointed out by now thinking it's a relatively very simple deduction and I thought someone somewhere should had done some research on that or even just plain stated the hypothesis. So, I'm asking either for a reference paper showing evidence for the evolution of de novo protein domain unknown by now from a random piece of DNA that somehow managed to turn into a gene or for a reference to a paper discussing the idea that all proteins originate from a common ancestor existing at the onset of life and even, possibly, a single domain as old as life itself?

P.S. Am I mislooking something or is this hypothesis something new for molecular biology-with all that effort gone into identifying relationships between protein domains I'm thinking it's very strange no one has hypothesized a single "mother" domain for all life. Are there some mechanisms that could generate novel domains from non-coding DNA I had overlooked when searching the journals and if there are to what field do then pertain to?

Can a novel protein domain arize de novo in Nature or did all protein domains evolve from a single ancestor?

I know there is extensive research into the taxonomy and evolution of protein domains and many connections are, and are continuing to be, found between numerous domains. However, as far as I can see, new domains always arise from preexisting ones. I have seen no paper, in any field, showing the development of a new protein domain from a random piece of DNA which just mutates a start codon and synthesizes a new protein with no apparent function. I know this is theoretically possible but has anyone seen any evidence it has happened in any form of life in any geological period of time? OR are there some other mechanisms that could generate novel domains from non-coding DNA that I have overlooked when searching the journals?

My thinking is that, if de novo protein domain generation doesn't occurr, does it mean that all protein domains are a kind of "progeny" of a single domain that arose at the onset of life as we know it (or maybe even was the first lifeform on Earth). It seems very strange to me that this hasn't been pointed out by now since it's a relatively simple deduction. Thus, I'm asking either for a reference paper showing evidence for the evolution of de novo protein domains from a random piece of DNA that somehow managed to turn into a gene or for a reference to a paper discussing the idea that all proteins originate from a common ancestor existing at the onset of life and even, possibly, a single domain as old as life itself?

edited title
Link

Can a novel protein domain arize anewde novo in Nature or aredid all protein domains evolved from a single ancestor?

Source Link
Loading