A common fact is that Ammonia, Urea and Uric acid are the most common excreted metabolites and their removal needs varying amount of water, highest for ammonia (hence suited only for aquatic animals) and lowest for uric acid (suited for desert animals). Why is this so? Is it because of different solubility of these compounds in water or their toxicity? If it is the latter, how would excess water reduce the toxicity of a compound? This is a bit over-simplistic question, but I want to understand the tradeoffs involved in selecting the mode of excretion, ammonotelic, ureotelic, uricotelic.
Ammonia is more water soluble and also more toxic than either urea or uric acid but it is energetically less expensive. So, in regions where deficiency of water is not a problem, ammonia is an excretory product. Where water is scarce urea or uric acid is the excretory product but it is energetically more expensive to manufacture them. So, you can see an obvious trade off between energy expenditure and water conservation.
You can refer to any introductory biology book like campbell for further reading.
Ammonia : Most toxic , Easily Soluble , Less Energy Requirement
Urea :Moderately toxic , Moderately soluble , More energy requirement(As needed to be processed from ammonia
Uric Acid:Least toxic , Least soluble , Highest energy requirement ( As needed to be processed from ammonia )
It is obvious now what tradeoffs are involved.
The only tradeoff not deducible from above is that of the eggs/youngs. In birds, eggs are not permeable for water so the best option is to excrete waste in form of uric acid so that high concentration of waste does not build up. Uric acid is excreted in form of solid palette which can stay in the egg without any harm.
We can also think of tadpoles which live exclusively in water and so they excrete ammonia but the frogs live both in land and water and so while on land they excrete urea as dessication is the main problem there.
protected by Community♦ Dec 14 '17 at 9:06
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?