15
$\begingroup$

The most famous example of a sealed bottle garden is David Latimer's bottle with a Spiderworth plant, pictured below, which has been sealed for 40 years. My own attempt at a bottle garden is failing and I'm looking to "debug" what's going on.

My garden is a 2 litre glass jar filled with gravel, sand and soil, filling about a quarter of the jar. The soil is rather damp. I'm observing the following: When the bottle is sealed, plants such as moss, strawberry shoots and seeds thrive for a couple of weeks. They will then wilt and worms that had hitched a ride in the soil try to escape. When opening the bottle, there is a strong smell exactly like manure. The brief exchange of air when opening the bottle is enough to allow the plants to properly rot over the coming days, with mold only now spreading. (This proves that oxygen was depleted before I opened the jar) I removed the dead plants, sprinkled seeds on the soil and closed the jar. The seeds germinated and thrived for a couple of weeks until the process repeated.

At first look, it appears that when oxygen has been depleted, anaerobic bacteria take over, producing H2S, which I assume kill the plants. Or are they killed by changes in pH under high CO2 concentrations? Why does this not occur for all bottle gardens? Is the problem that there's too few plants to keep up the oxygen level which keeps the anaerobic bacteria at bay, is it the waterlogged soil or some other factor I'm unaware of?



Latimer's highly successful bottle garden
Latimer did something right with his bottle garden, which started with a seedling and some compost.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ @j.musser may be the one to say something intelligent about this, but did mr. Latimer on the photo perhaps use sterilized materials (flask, soil, water etc.,)? Even seeds can be treated to kill most germs. It seems that bacteria/fungi seem to thwart your goals. $\endgroup$ – AliceD Feb 11 '15 at 13:09
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @ChrisStronks: There appears to be a healthy bacterial culture in Latimer's flask. The bacteria decompose dead leaves from the spiderworth, turning these into soil and releasing CO2 for consumption by the plant, completing the carbon cycle. $\endgroup$ – Abulafia Feb 11 '15 at 13:51
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Have you ever played the Conway's Game of Life? From random beginnings you can have a fast-dying "life", or you can have an almost eternal "life". It probably has a big amount of chance going on. I heard that the project Biosfere II has had no luck at all, even with thousands of bottles... $\endgroup$ – Rodrigo Feb 11 '15 at 21:50
6
+150
$\begingroup$

The problem lies in soil bacteria. There has been a project on a larger scale: Biosphere 2. After their initial trial they realised $O_2$ levels are getting much lower from what was predicted. The scientists team investigated the problem deeper and came to the conclusion that there was a lot of dead organic matter in the soil, which got consumed by aerobic bacteria. There were also other hypotheses: not enough sunlight and $O_2$ sequestration by concrete.

A solution for you would be to make sure there is little organic matter in your soil. Perhaps use inorganic "soil" like sand + some nutrients. And also make sure there is enough sunlight. Start also with small plants - too large plants in the beginning might change $O_2/CO_2$ ratio to abruptly during day and night cycle. (remember that plants are also consuming oxygen at night).

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ That would make sense, the H2S (if that's what it is) occurs because the bacteria are gobbling up oxygen faster than the plants can produce it. I'll reduce the soil content and make it less waterlogged $\endgroup$ – Abulafia Feb 17 '15 at 10:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.