In Guyton and Hall Textbook of Medical Physiology (12e) the retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) are classified into W, X, and Y types. However, in Gray's Anatomy (40th ed.), RGS are subdivided into midget and parasol cells. What is the relationship between the W-X-Y versus midget-parasol classifications?

Summary of the WXY classification as in Medical Physiology:

About 40% ganglion cells are W cells. They are the smallest (<10 μm), and the slowest (8 m/s) to transmit signals, but they have the broadest receptive field. They receive signals from rods and detect directional movement.

About 55% are X cells. They have medium size (10~15 μm) and transmission speed (14 m/s). Their fields are small. They transmit color vision.

About 5% are Y cells. They are the largest (<35 μm) and the fastest (35 m/s) to transmit signals. They have broad fields. They respond to rapid changes in the vision.


Short answer
X = P = midget = β
Y = M = parasol = α
W = γ

First off, P and M cells are not equal to parasol and midget cells; on the contrary - P cells are midgets and M cells are considered to be parasols.

X, Y and W cells are used to denote different retinal ganglion cells in cats, as proposed by experiments Enroth-Gubel & Robson (1966). As you already indicate, these cells have different physiological response properties. X and Y cells have the standard center-surround distribution of their receptive field, X cells having linear additive response properties in center and surround and Y cells nonlinear properties. X cells therefore have predictive responses such that responses can be predicted to be maximal (e.g. light shining on the ON center and no light stimulation on the OFF surround). Y cells tend to respond in more complex ways. W cells do not have a center-surround structure (Bruce et al, 1996).

Based on morphology, retinal ganglion cells in the cat have been labelled α, β and γ cells, which are thought to correspond to the physiological classes of Y, X and W cells, respectively (Boycott & H. Wässle, 1974).

The P and M division was introduced by De Monasterio & Gouras (1975) based on monkey experiments. P and M refer to the parvocellular and magnocellular connections retinal ganglion cells in monkeys make in the LGN of the brain. Both types of cells have a center-surround receptive field structure like X and Y cells in the cat. P cells show color opponency and respond to specific wavelengths of light, and are involved in color vision. P cells respond to a range of wavelengths and respond most vigorous when different light intensities illuminate the center and surround (Bruce et al, 1996).

P cells are considered to be mostly midget ganglion cells, and equivalent to β cells of cat. M cells, on the other hand are considered to be mostly parasol cells and resembling α cells (Kolb, 2001).

- Boycott & H. Wässle, J Physiol (1974); 240(2): 397–419
- Bruce et al, Visual Perception (1996); 3rd ed. Psychology Press
- De Monasterio & Gouras, J Physiol (1975); 251(1): 167–95
- Enroth-Gubel & Robson, J Physiol (1966); 187(3): 517–52
- Kolb H. Webvision (2001). Salt Lake City (UT): University of Utah Health Sciences Center


According to Comparative Vertebrate Neuroanatomy, the XYW classfication is used for cat retina. They roughly correspond to the M, P, K cells in primates, respectively.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.