ALS is a fatal motor neuron disease, and even though there are many different articles out there on the topic "How does ALS actually kill you?", none of them really delve deep enough into biology to adequately answer the question.

For instance, many articles cite "respiratory failure", or "CO2 poisoning". But the last time I checked, ALS doesn't make your lungs explode or cause your body to start producing toxic levels of CO2. So obviously, we need another level of detail here to support these claims. I'd be willing to be that with "respiratory failure", either the neurons innervating the diaphragm break down (hence you become physically unable to draw air in and push CO2 out), or perhaps the tiny/micronic structures inside your alveoli become impaired for some reason. If the former, then why wouldn't a ventilator/respirator help the patient?

Either way, I'm interested in a biological/neurological explanation for why ALS is considered to be (ultimately) fatal.


TL;DR Ventilation assistance does help but there are other factors.

ALS is a degeneration of the motor neurons, replacing them with hard material (i.e. sclerosis). The neurons innervating the muscles involved in respiration deteriorate and so it becomes difficult to breath, swallow, cough, etc. There's a compounding effect: we know that blood O2 and CO2 levels are balanced by respiration, O2 in/CO2 out, and we know that swallowing/coughing clear secretions from the respiratory tract. Basically you end up with trouble oxygenating your blood and riding it of CO2, hence CO2 poisoning. This can result in what is known as type 2 respiratory failure, characterized by low oxygen and high carbon dioxide levels (hypoxemia and hypercapnia). Low secretion clearance in the lungs can also result in aspiration pneumonia in addition to poor gas exchange.

Ventilation methods such as BCV are capable of mechanically assisting breathing, and maintaining ventilation-perfusion state in a way that prevents respiratory failure, but unfortunately doesn't slow the progression of the disease. The problem then is that in, for example, particularly severe cases, the quality of life has to be taken into account because tongue movement, gross movement in general due to motor neuron degeneration just fails. This can lead to what is essentially locked-in syndrome (LIS), and clinical outcomes can widely vary, though in this article they report the more pleasant outcomes of patients experiencing LIS. I think that for these cases due to poor communicaton patient-reported outcomes are fairly underreported, but family and caregivers at this point have to take into serious consideration options such as euthanasia. Cutting off ventilation can result in type 1 or 2 respiratory failure.

Now, I lack actual data for this statement but I should also point out that not all patients receive the same care or opt for assisted ventilation, in which case late-stage ALS would invariably lead to total neurodegeneration to breathing muscle innervation, where assisted ventilation becomes a requirement for survival.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks @Kendall (+1) - however I'm missing a big part of your explanation!! In your 2nd paragraph you state "Basically you end up with trouble oxygenating your blood and riding it of CO2, hence CO2 poisoning."... but why?!? Is it because you can't swallow/cough/etc. to clear your respiratory track of secretions (meaning, if there's mucuous in your throat, you won't be able to suck air in or let CO2 escape)? Or is some other mechanism at play that actually prevents proper O2/CO2 exchange? Thanks again! $\endgroup$ – smeeb Feb 9 '16 at 16:44
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Secretions that block the alveolar gas exchange is one reason, not just in the throat but also down in the lung, and shallow/strained breathing is another. $\endgroup$ – CKM Feb 9 '16 at 17:37
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks again @Kendall (+1) - last followup question here, I promise (!): can I assume that eventually all motor neurons will be affected, including those controlling heartbeat and digestive motility (that is, moving food from end to end, so to speak)? Thanks again! $\endgroup$ – smeeb Feb 9 '16 at 17:41
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ ALS does not affect the innervation of the heart, digestive organs or urinary organs. $\endgroup$ – CKM Feb 9 '16 at 17:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.