2
$\begingroup$

I have read

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomical_terms_of_motion#Flexion_and_extension

"Flexion ... decreases the angle...Extension is the opposite of flexion, describing a straightening movement that increases the angle between body parts"

I am clear on the directions of flexion and extension

enter image description here

So all agree on direction, but if I look up degrees of flexion, for example

enter image description here

and videos showing usage of a goniometer to measure shoulder flexion, which echo that picture, so 180 degrees is the arm up, and 0 degrees is the arm down.

What I don't quite understand, is that flexion according to wikipedia, should decrease the angle. Whereas looking at the degrees in that diagram, and in videos of usage of a goniometer, the more flexion you have, the higher the degree.

I can think of two possible resolutions

A) that wikipedia has missed out that in fact, for the case of the arm, flexion increases the angle. Whereas for bending movement, it decreases it.

or

B) the planes that describe degree of flexion, are different to the ones shown on a goniometer, perhaps, one field uses a gynometer, the other uses a measure with the angles going the other direction

I'm guessing that it's "A" , that wikipedia is misleading and in the case of the "shoulder"(the arm movement considered shoulder flexion and extension), flexion doesn't decrease the angle, it increases it(though wikipedia doesn't say that). But i'd be interested if that can be confirmed.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ For A), it depends on how you define the angle. If 180 is directed at the floor, then it is correct. The problem is that with the shoulder "increase" and "decrease" are ambiguous, and you have to define your planes of reference explicitly. $\endgroup$ – kmm Oct 14 '16 at 12:17
  • $\begingroup$ @kmm well there's no question what planes we are talking about. One plane is the frontal plane, the other plane is the plane made by the arm straight out in front going all the way up and all the way down at angles between 0 and 180. Sagittal plane. Both wikipedia and that picture and the goniometer are using the same planes. One could say there is a difference depending on which you define as zero and which as 180,but clearly a goniometer uses a standard convention of goniometers.. what standard convention is wikipedia using? What other texts measure shoulder flexion the way wikipedia does? $\endgroup$ – barlop Oct 14 '16 at 12:27
2
$\begingroup$

There are two criteria to differ between flexion and extension:

1) Decreasing or increasing the angle between the involved bones. By this criteria, it should be clear that flexion means bending of the elbows and knees and lateral bending of the spine (the neck and torso) toward the bent side.

2. The anterior/posterior direction of the movement. All anterior (ventral) movements in the neck or torso part of the spine, shoulder, elbow, wrist, fingers, hip, ankle and toes are called flexion and all posterior (dorsal) movements (except in the knee) are called extension.

You should not use the both criteria at the same time, because they can contradict each other.

There are some specifics:

  • In the wrist, you can have palmar flexion, dorsiflexion (extension), ulnar flexion (abduction) and radial flexion (adduction) (Teachmeanatomy).
  • In the ankle, you can have plantar flexion, dorsiflexion (extension), inversion (inward rotation, adduction) and eversion (outward rotation, abduction). (ScienceDirect).
  • In the shoulder and hip, raising a limb to the same side as the limb is, is abduction (lateral extension) and raising it to the opposite side is adduction.
  • Moving the thumb toward the palm (in the same plane as palm) is flexion (adduction) and moving it away from it is extension (abduction).

You can read about flexion and extension and other movements here: Types of Body Movements (BCcampus)

Flexion and extension are movements that take place within the sagittal plane and involve anterior or posterior movements of the body or limbs. For the vertebral column, flexion (anterior flexion) is an anterior (forward) bending of the neck or body, while extension involves a posterior-directed motion, such as straightening from a flexed position or bending backward. Lateral flexion is the bending of the neck or body toward the right or left side.

In the limbs, flexion decreases the angle between the bones (bending of the joint), while extension increases the angle and straightens the joint. For the upper limb, all anterior-going motions are flexion and all posterior-going motions are extension. These include anterior-posterior movements of the arm at the shoulder, the forearm at the elbow, the hand at the wrist, and the fingers at the metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints. For the thumb, extension moves the thumb away from the palm of the hand, within the same plane as the palm, while flexion brings the thumb back against the index finger or into the palm. These motions take place at the first carpometacarpal joint. In the lower limb, bringing the thigh forward and upward is flexion at the hip joint, while any posterior-going motion of the thigh is extension. Note that extension of the thigh beyond the anatomical (standing) position is greatly limited by the ligaments that support the hip joint. Knee flexion is the bending of the knee to bring the foot toward the posterior thigh, and extension is the straightening of the knee. Flexion and extension movements are seen at the hinge, condyloid, saddle, and ball-and-socket joints of the limbs (see Figure 1).

Now, to answer the question about the goniometer.

enter image description here

Again, the confusion about interpretation of this goniometer arises from two different criteria about flexion. The one mentioned in the Wikipedia and other anatomical articles says that in flexion the angle between the involved bones decreases. When you raise your arm, this criteria does not aply because the angle between the bones (humerus/scapula) in the shoulder joint does not really change (unlike in the elbow, for example), so here the criteria that all anterior movements are considered flexion applies. When you have an arm straight down, there is no flexion, so it's considered zero degrees and when it's straight up, it's considered 180 degrees, so the angle is increasing, but this is not an angle between the arm and other bones or the body but between the starting and ending position of the arm.

$\endgroup$
8
  • $\begingroup$ you write "During raising the arm, the angle is closing" <-- the angle between what and what? between arm and torso? I suppose you could say the angle is closing/reducing whether the arm is near fully down or fully up, depending on whether 0 is at the top or at the bottom $\endgroup$ – barlop Sep 4 '19 at 22:11
  • $\begingroup$ @barlop, I have changed the last part about goniometer. In this case, you should not think about any "body" angles, but just about goniometer angles. $\endgroup$ – Jan Sep 5 '19 at 6:31
  • $\begingroup$ So in the case of criteria 1 (bending flexion), flexion decreases the angle, and in the case of criteria 2, (direction of movement flexion), flexion increases the angle? $\endgroup$ – barlop Sep 5 '19 at 7:39
  • $\begingroup$ @barlop By criteria 1, flexion decreases the angle between the actual bones (like in the elbow or knee). But when you raise your arm, in the shoulder joint, there is no real change in angle between the humerus and scapula, so this criteria simply does not work here, so the criteria 2 (any anterior movement is flexion) applies. Now, even if by criteria 2, the "theoretical" or goniometric angle increases when you raise your arm, you can't generalize this for other movements. For example, when you bend your neck forward, by criteria 2 this is flexion...continued... $\endgroup$ – Jan Sep 5 '19 at 8:05
  • $\begingroup$ Looking from the front, the angle between the spinal vertebra decreases, but looking from the back it increases. You just need to know, which criteria applies to a particular joint and be aware that the angle that decreases can be real, physical (by crieria 1) or arbitrary by criteria 2 (forward movement is flexion). By criteria 1, flexion always decresaes the angle between the bones, and by criteria 2, it depends on the joint. $\endgroup$ – Jan Sep 5 '19 at 8:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.