4
$\begingroup$

Articles from the aquaticcommunity.com and the Nature Conservancy suggest that freshwater jellyfish, Craspedacusta sowerbyi, are more closely related to the Genus Hydra. From the Nature Conservancy article:

It should be known that though Craspedacusta sowerbii is touted as a jellyfish, some argue it is more related to the family Hydra than a "true" jellyfish. Many researchers still call it as such, but others may simply refer Craspedacusta as a jelly. The main difference between Craspedacusta swerbii and "true" jellyfish is the presence of a velum. Its velum is a thin, circular membrane around the cap that helps propel, or move, the jelly forward.

An articles from the US Geological Survey (USGS) states that Craspedacusta sowerbyi is a hydrozoan that can take the form of a jellyfish. From the USGS:

Craspedacusta sowerbyi is a hydrozoan (Phylum Cnidaria, Class Hydrozoa), which is most easily identified when it takes the form of a small, bell-shaped jellyfish, known as a hydromedusa.

The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines a jellyfish as follows:

a free-swimming marine coelenterate that is the sexually reproducing form of a hydrozoan or scyphozoan and has a nearly transparent saucer-shaped body and extensible marginal tentacles studded with stinging cells

This definition, to me, seems to suggest that Craspedacusta sowerbyi is a jellyfish, however there must be some other reasoning that I'm missing that makes others believe that they aren't. Any clarification would be greatly appreciated.

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

The issue here is simply the meaning of the term "jellyfish" and the term "medusa". The first has no taxonomic value and, as such, can be used the way the book/zoologist/layman/journalist wants, unfortunately. Let's see it:

Cnidarians (Phylum Cnidaria) have two basic morphological types: medusa, or medusoid form, which is free-swimming, and polyp, or polypoid form, which is sessile:

enter image description here

There are Cnidarian species that display only polypoid forms and there are species that display both medusoid and polypoid forms in their life cycles.

Regarding the taxonomy of the most common Classes of Cnidarians, Hydrozoa displays both the polypoid and medusoid forms; Scyphozoa displays both the polypoid and medusoid forms; and finally Anthozoa displays only polypoid forms.

So, we can clearly see that Craspedacusta (an hydrozoan) is a medusa, or, in other words, that it displays the medusoid form in some point of its life cycle. There is no doubt regarding this:

enter image description here

The problem comes when we try to use the term jellyfish.

Again, jellyfish has absolutely no taxonomic value. For instance, my teachers used to call an hydrozoan medusa as a "jellyfish". Some time later, when I started teaching zoology, I used to say to my students that an hydrozoan medusa is a jellyfish... that's not a big deal.

However, some zoologists apply the term jellyfish only to the scyphozoan medusae... in that case, jellyfish does have a taxonomic value. And, because of that, since Craspedacusta belongs to the Class Hydrozoa, its medusoid form cannot be called a jellyfish (again, if we accept the definition of those zoologists).

So, in conclusion, it depends on the book/zoologist: some say that that both Hydrozoan and Schyphozoan medusae can be called jellyfish, while some say that jellyfishes are only the medusoid forms from the Class Schyphozoa. That's the definition used by both the aquaticcommunity.com and the Nature Conservancy articles.

PS: Hydra is a Genus, not a Family. I edited your question just to realize that the mistake is from the original article, not yours.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ I was starting to wonder if it depended on who is asked but could never have come to this conclusion on my own. Excellent explanation. $\endgroup$ – wanderweeer Nov 24 '17 at 22:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.