2
$\begingroup$

Which molecule, in excess, inhibits beta-oxidation?

a. Acetyl-CoA

b. Malonyl-CoA

The answer to this question seems debatable to me, as I think both are correct. However, according to my professor, only one is correct — which one I don’t know because it was a question from the final exam.

Acety-CoA can inhibit thiolase, and malonyl-CoA can inhibit CAT I (Carnitine- acyltransferase), both of which lead to the same outcome — inhibiting beta-oxidation

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

Mammalian $\beta$-oxidation occurs in the mitochondrion, whereas fatty acid biosynthesis is cytoplasmic.

  • The rate-limiting in mammalian fatty acid oxidation is considered to be carnitine palmitoyltransferase (CAT), a key enzyme in the transport of acetyl-CoA across the inner mitochondrial membrane. This enzyme is inhibited by low micromolar concentrations of malonyl-CoA (see Beta oxidation of fatty acids by H. Schulz).

Malonyl-CoA, of course, is a key intermediate in fatty acid biosynthesis. Salih Wakil showed that CO2 is required for fatty acid biosynthesis, but that carbon atoms from CO2 do not appear in fatty acids, and it is now known that this is due to the formation of .malonyl-CoA by acetyI-CoA carboxylase, the rate-limiting reaction of fatty acid synthesis.

  • Thus when fatty acid biosynthesis is taking place, the concentration of malonyl-CoA is high and CAT (and therefore $\beta$-oxidation) is inhibited (Schulz, 1991).

However, as the OP points out, micromolar concentrations of acetyl-CoA inhibit 3-ketoacyI-CoA thiolase when the concentration of CoASH is low, and the Acetyl-CoA/CoASH ratio within the mitochondrion may also play a role in the regulation of beta-oxidation (Schulz, 1991).

As the OP says, it is a debatable point, and it seems to me, an example of a badly worded exam question. I think the 'expected' answer is probably malonyl-CoA, and there is no doubt that this molecule plays a key role in the regulation of both fatty acid oxidation and fatty acid biosynthesis. Nevertheless, the inhibition of thiolase by Acetyl-CoA may also play a role in the regulation of beta-oxidation.

Perhaps your Professor is an example of the type that Warburg told Hans Krebs to attach himself to? :-)

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Your Google books link tells me I have reached a page I cannot access. Perhaps you can give us the Warburg quotation, in the German original if possible. $\endgroup$ – David Dec 18 '18 at 18:45
  • $\begingroup$ The story is attributed to Krebs, I think when he was at Sheffield. I have taken the quote from 'Hitler's Gift' by Jean Medawar and David Pyke. "Warburg, a biochemist with outstanding gifts of intellectual insight, had told Krebs that, if he wanted a University career, 'You had better attach yourself to some old ass of a professor'. Krebs wisely attached himself to Warburg for four years, during which he published 16 papers on biochemical subjects". I think Homes in his biography of Krebs gives a slightly different version of the quote. $\endgroup$ – user1136 Dec 18 '18 at 21:10
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Taken me a while to get to it, but I finally found the quotation in Krebs’ (English language) autobiography of 1981, Reminiscences and Reflections. On p. 26 he gives this account of his interview with Warburg “I could learn a lot in his laboratory, he said, but if it were my aim to make a university career, ‘Then you had better attach yourself to some old ass of a professor.’” He goes on to write: “Warburg kept his word on both counts: he taught me a great deal, and he did not actively help me find a post…” $\endgroup$ – David May 29 at 12:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.