The field of what might cause cramps is quite contested with a lot of controversy around the heat/dehydration cramps, but I find it surprising that no specific theories appear to have been proposed (or tested) while swimming, usually in cold[er] water. There's one governmental site that does acknowledge cold and cold water in particular as a risk factor. I for one never get cramps in a pool/water over 18 degree C, but I am quite likely to get them below that, no matter what I do in terms of stretching, drinking etc. (There's one other site that mentions that "muscle spasms" occur during cold-water shock, below 15 degreed C.) Am I correct that no specific theories have been proposed or tested for cold-related cramps?

Interestingly, the cutoff temperature I found experimentally for myself is perhaps reflected in one article:

during swimming at a water temperature of 18 [deg] C, it is noted that esophageal and muscular temperatures tend to decrease, below 37 [deg] C. [3 refs cited for this fact]

So below 18 C water temperature it appears that consistent cooling of the muscles occurs. So I guess one could ask, equivalently, why muscle cooling [below 37 C] can lead to cramps.



Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.