Here's an interesting question I've been trying to figure out:

enter image description here enter image description here

My annotations are in red. So far, I've figured out:

  • We know 630 colonies survived when plated with ACD antibiotics...meaning they picked up the a/c/d resistance alleles, but remain wild-type for the b allele. The genotype would be "a b+ c d". Because SO MANY (630!) colonies seemed to inherit a/c/d together, and b completely separate from them, I would say b is the gene quite distant from the 3 other genes.

However, I've unsure about how to proceed and determine the probably order of the 3 others genes: a, c, and d.

Here's my hunch: B--------------------C-D-A.

I'll explain:

  • Well, I looked and saw 942 (many!!!) picked up A/D together. So A/D are probably adjacent.

  • Then, 786 (many, but fewer) picked up C/D together. So C is further from D than A is far from D. The question becomes: is it "C---A-D" or is it "A-D---C"?

  • The insight comes in with 640 (still fewer) picked up A/C together. That means A is actually quite FAR from C, because more distance = more recombination events that could split them up. So between the "C---A-D" or "A-D---C" listed above, it's more likely "A-D---C".

  • Okay! We know B is far from the other ones, BUT is it like "B-------ADC", or is it like "ADC-------B"? Well, let's look: picked up B/C together is 51, but picked up A/B together is only 46. That means A is a little FURTHER from B than C is further from B, since 46 < 51.

    • This led me to my proposed answer: that the order is "ADC---------B", or if you just flip it around, its equivalent: "B---------CDA".

How's my reasoning? This stuff can be pretty confusing; am I approaching it from the right angles? Thanks so much; really appreciate it!

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You were never told that all the genes were on a single plasmid. I think you should treat all those counts < 50 as essentially zero; cells pretty much never get both the ACD and the B plasmid; they get one or the other. $\endgroup$
    – swbarnes2
    Oct 18 '19 at 16:37

I think your reasoning is sound and your ordering very likely, but I wouldn't feel comfortable with deciding the side B is on. Actually, it's more than that: I think that by using basically the same number (~40) for everything that includes B, they want you to come to another conclusion.

Unlike eukaryotic cells undergoing meiosis, there is no crossing over in bacteria taking up DNA from the surroundings. Therefore, it shouldn't be possible for the cell to inherit A, B and C but not D, which is in the middle. Simply, from my understanding of the "experimental" setup, they added antibiotics A, B and C, so they have to assume the bacteria are wild type for D. However, it's basically for sure that those ABC-resistant colonies are also D-resistant.

Still, your reasoning is correct: comparing BC and AB should give you the side B is on, since the break could have been inside of the 3-gene cluster. However, the numbers are very close, and the "AB" and "BC" phenotypes are probably ABCD anyway, making the small difference even less meaningful (the true AB and BC are lost because they are mixed with the many ABCD).


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.